L E X T I F F

Loading

Plaintiff case management software built exclusively for personal injury and contingency law firms.

CONTACT US
Contact

Lextiff vs MyCase

  • Home
  • Compare Lextiff vs MyCase
Lextiff vs MyCase

Lextiff vs MyCase.
Which is right for your firm?

MyCase is a popular legal platform known for its clean interface. But like most general legal software, it wasn't built around the specific workflow of contingency fee plaintiff firms.

Start free trial → Book a demo

No credit card required · Setup same day

Same day

Setup vs days

Included

SOL tracking built in

No contract

Month-to-month only

100%

Plaintiff-focused

Side by side

Feature comparison

A straightforward look at how the two platforms compare.

Feature Lextiff MyCase
Built for plaintiff firms ✓ ✓ Exclusively All firm types
SOL tracking ✓ ✓ Built in — all 50 states Manual entry
Settlement calculations ✓ ✓ Included Not native
Lien management ✓ ✓ Included Not available
Expense tracking ✓ ✓ With approvals Basic
Client portal ✓ ✓ Included Included
E-signatures ✓ ✓ Built in Included
Intake forms ✓ ✓ Branded — 24/7 Available
Same-day setup ✓ ✓ Yes Days
Contract ✓ Month-to-month Annual
Pricing ✓ Contact us $39–89/user/mo
Migration support ✓ ✓ Included Limited

Pricing and feature information based on publicly available data. Verify current details directly with each vendor.

The context

MyCase wasn't built only for plaintiff firms.

MyCase is clean, modern, and accessible. But it was designed for general law practice. Plaintiff firms using MyCase often find themselves working around the platform rather than with it — tracking SOL deadlines externally and managing settlement math in spreadsheets.

→ No built-in SOL tracking for plaintiff cases
→ Settlement calculations not native to the platform
→ Lien management requires external tools
→ General workflows don't match plaintiff firm needs
→ Billing-focused features not relevant to contingency firms
→ Annual contracts on most plans

"MyCase looked clean and easy to use. But when we needed SOL tracking across 40 active cases and settlement math that showed liens and expenses, we hit a wall."

— Why plaintiff firms look for alternatives

Strengths by platform

Where each platform shines.

Every platform has strengths. Understanding the difference helps you choose the right one for your firm.

MyCase is strong for:

  • • Clean, easy-to-use interface
  • • Good client portal and communication tools
  • • Affordable entry-level pricing
  • • Solid document management
  • • Works well for general practice firms
  • • Good mobile experience

Lextiff is strong for:

  • ✓ Built exclusively for plaintiff firms — no adaptation needed
  • ✓ SOL built in for all 50 states — auto-calculated
  • ✓ Settlement distributions with lien tracking native
  • ✓ Expense approval workflows built in
  • ✓ Client portal included and designed for PI clients
  • ✓ Same-day setup — onboarding included
  • ✓ Month-to-month pricing

The experience difference.

What switching to Lextiff actually looks like for a plaintiff firm.

❌ MyCase for plaintiff firms

✗

SOL deadlines tracked in spreadsheets or calendars

✗

Settlement math done outside the platform

✗

Liens tracked manually — often missed

✗

General workflows require workarounds for plaintiff practice

✗

Paying for features contingency firms don't need

✗

Annual commitment before workflow fit is confirmed

✓ Lextiff for plaintiff firms

✓

Plaintiff-specific from the start

✓

SOL auto-calculated — no spreadsheets

✓

Settlement distributions calculated instantly with liens

✓

Expense recovery tracked with approval workflows

✓

Client portal built for PI client communication

✓

Month-to-month — cancel anytime

Migration

Moving from MyCase doesn't have to be painful.

Lextiff can help firms transition from MyCase with assisted migration. Our team handles the heavy lifting so your firm doesn't lose momentum.

  • ✓ Cases and matter history
  • ✓ Client contacts and records
  • ✓ Documents and uploaded files
  • ✓ Notes and case communications
  • ✓ Expenses and cost records
  • ✓ Deadline and calendar data
  • ✓ Settlement records

What migration looks like:

1 We review your current MyCase setup
2 We prepare your Lextiff account and import structure
3 Cases, documents, and contacts are migrated
4 Your team is onboarded — usually in one session
5 You're live — same day in most cases

Migration assistance is included with every Lextiff subscription. No extra cost. No migration consultants. Just our team helping yours.

Which platform is right for you

Which platform is right for you?

An honest answer — because the right fit matters more than the sale.

Choose MyCase if:

  • → You run a general practice firm with diverse cases
  • → You prioritize a simple, low-cost platform
  • → Your workflow doesn't require SOL tracking or settlement math
  • → You serve hourly billing clients primarily
Recommended

Choose Lextiff if:

  • ✓ You run a personal injury, mass tort, or workers comp firm
  • ✓ You need SOL tracking built in for every case
  • ✓ You want settlement calculations and lien tracking included
  • ✓ You want same-day setup with no annual contract
  • ✓ You work on contingency and need plaintiff-specific tools
Common questions

Frequently asked questions.

Yes. We assist firms migrating from MyCase — including cases, contacts, documents, and matter history. Migration support is included.

Yes. SOL is auto-calculated for every case type across all 50 states. Alerts go out at 180, 90, 30, and 7 days automatically.

Yes. Enter any settlement amount and see the exact client payout after attorney fees, liens, and expenses — instantly.

No. Month-to-month only. Cancel anytime.

Yes. Guided onboarding is included with every Lextiff subscription.

Yes — specifically personal injury, mass tort, workers comp, and solo plaintiff attorneys.

Built for plaintiff attorneys who win.

Not every law firm needs enterprise complexity.

Lextiff gives plaintiff firms the tools they need — without the overhead, configuration, or cost of general legal software.

Start free trial → Book a demo

No credit card required · Setup same day · Cancel anytime